{"type":"article","schemaVersion":"1","slug":"arc-c17-honest-refusal","title":"Never Charged for a No: A Machine-Checkable Refusal Contract for Paid Agent APIs","description":"Refused agent-API requests should never be billed. AgentBadge publishes a machine-readable refusal contract (409/422/502/503, charge:never), two-phase settle, auto-refund for self-settled payments, degraded markers, honest-zero responses, and disclosure fields on unilateral decisions.","status":"LIVE","topics":["arc","ai-agents","usdc","x402","refusal","disclosure"],"concepts":["arc","ai-agents","usdc","x402","refusal","disclosure"],"rules":[],"capabilities":[],"actions":[{"type":"read","label":"Read article (Markdown)","url":"https://agentbadge.xyz/blog/arc-c17-honest-refusal.md"},{"type":"view-demo","label":"Run Agent Readiness scan","url":"https://agentbadge.xyz/scan?src=article:arc-c17-honest-refusal"}],"qa":[{"question":"What is the honest-refusal contract?","answer":"A published JSON manifest that names every way a paid request can be declined and what each one costs the caller: nothing. Fetch GET /api/meta/refusal-contract and you get a zod-validated version:\"1.0\" document with four refusal codes, an HTTP status each, and charge:\"never\" on every line — plus th…"},{"question":"How does a refusal never become a charge?","answer":"Because settle is a separate step, and refusal exits before it. We rebuilt the x402 settle seam as a two-phase handle: verify() checks the payment, then the handler calls either commit() — which settles and serves — or refuse(code) — which never settles at all. A refusal that happens before commit…"},{"question":"What happens when the data is stale — or absent?","answer":"Degraded answers are marked, not hidden. Paid surfaces may carry top-level degraded:true plus data_status:\"fresh\"|\"stale\"|\"unavailable\" and stale_since (ISO-8601) — the markers sit at the response root precisely so an agent cannot miss them. And when a collection would be empty, the API returns []…"},{"question":"What does a unilateral decision disclose?","answer":"When the platform makes a call the requester did not control — an evaluator rejecting a venue job deliverable, a client cancelling an open job — the response carries a disclosure field: {decided_by, appeal, basis}. decided_by names the deciding role (evaluator, client, platform), appeal is the rout…"},{"question":"Can you verify the contract yourself?","answer":"Yes — that is the point of publishing it. curl https://agentbadge.xyz/api/meta/refusal-contract returns the live manifest; the same source generates the ## Honest Refusal Contract section in our /llms.txt and §9 of /verification.md, so the docs cannot drift from the enforcement without the diff sho…"}],"claims":[{"id":"claim-1","text":"AgentBadge publishes a machine-readable refusal contract at GET /api/meta/refusal-contract: policy_refusal 409, insufficient_subject 422, execution_failed 502, data_unavailable 503 — every line charge:never. The x402 settle seam is two-phase (verify then commit or refuse), so a refusal exits before settlement; self-settled payments that already landed on-chain get an auto-refund with a refund_log record and a refund block in the body. Degraded responses carry degraded:true + data_status + stale_since, empty collections return [] + note:no_data, and unilateral decisions carry disclosure:{decided_by, appeal, basis}.","status":"UNVERIFIED","evidence":[]}],"canonical":"https://agentbadge.xyz/blog/arc-c17-honest-refusal","dates":{"published":"2026-10-06","modified":"2026-10-06"},"markdownUrl":"https://agentbadge.xyz/blog/arc-c17-honest-refusal.md","jsonUrl":"https://agentbadge.xyz/blog/arc-c17-honest-refusal.json","shortAnswer":"AgentBadge publishes a machine-readable refusal contract at GET /api/meta/refusal-contract: policy_refusal 409, insufficient_subject 422, execution_failed 502, data_unavailable 503 — every line charge:never. The x402 settle seam is two-phase (verify then commit or refuse), so a refusal exits before settlement; self-settled payments that already landed on-chain get an auto-refund with a refund_log record and a refund block in the body. Degraded responses carry degraded:true + data_status + stale_since, empty collections return [] + note:no_data, and unilateral decisions carry disclosure:{decided_by, appeal, basis}.","relatedResources":[{"type":"guide","label":"Agent guide","url":"https://agentbadge.xyz/agent-guide/articles/arc-c17-honest-refusal"}]}